I think this is on my holiday wish list every year, but it's been my favorite eyeliner forever!
I would love more of the Make Up Forever Aqua XL Waterproof Eye Pencil. I like any of the dark colors (blacks, browns), and want to think I'd be all creative with lighter ones, but I wouldn't. LOL I bought them myself one year and I think they're still in my makeup pile. So darker colors it is.
If you have a great mascara to recommend, let me know that! I've just been buying whatever lately. It works well enough, but an awesome one would be, well, awesome!